Best Plush Dog Toys for Durable and Safe Play in 2025

Plush dog toys are a popular choice for pet owners who want to give their dogs something soft and fun to play with. These toys are made with fabric and stuffing, making them gentle on a dog’s teeth and good for cuddling. Many dogs enjoy plush toys because they feel like a companion or a treasure to carry around.

These toys come in lots of shapes and sizes, from small animals to balls and even food-shaped toys. Plush toys can help keep dogs entertained and reduce boredom, which can stop destructive behavior. However, not all plush toys are made the same, and some hold up better to chewing than others.

When choosing the best plush dog toy, it’s important to look at the material quality, stitching, and how safe the toy is. Some toys use non-toxic fabrics and have reinforced seams to last longer. It’s also critical to consider the size of the toy to match your dog’s breed and chewing style. We tested many popular plush dog toys to find the ones that hold up well and keep dogs happy.

Best Plush Dog Toys

We have tested and reviewed many plush dog toys to find the best options for durability, safety, and fun. Our list includes toys that suit different dog sizes and play styles. Choose from these trusted picks to keep your dog happy and entertained.

Best Pet Supplies Duck Toy

This duck-shaped plush toy is a solid choice for dogs needing a gentle, mess-free chew toy that still keeps them entertained.

Pros

• No stuffing means less mess and safer play.
• Soft crinkle sounds keep dogs interested.
• Durable fabric stands up to moderate chewing.

Cons

• Thin material may not last with very strong chewers.
• Squeaker can be pulled out by determined dogs.
• Not suitable for aggressive chewers who destroy toys quickly.

We found the no stuffing design helpful for keeping our floors clean. The crinkle noise is just enough to catch a dog’s attention without being too loud or annoying in the house. Our dogs enjoyed tossing and carrying it around easily because of the duck’s size and shape.

The toy is softer on teeth and gums compared to hard rubber or rope toys, which made it great for puppies and older pups. The build feels light but fairly sturdy thanks to the reinforced stitching. Still, if you have a very heavy chewer, this may not be the best long-term option.

Overall, it works well for indoor play and bonding time. We like that it stays intact without any fluff flying everywhere, reducing cleanup. Just keep an eye on the squeaker part if your dog tends to go after it.

Lambchop Plush Dog Toy

This toy is a solid choice for dogs who like soft, cuddly plushies with a fun squeaker.

Pros

• Very soft and cuddly material
• Squeaker adds excitement to play
• Good size for small to medium dogs

Cons

• Not very durable for heavy chewers
• Needs supervision during play
• Can be smaller than expected

We found the Lambchop plush toy to be a great comfort for dogs that enjoy soft toys to cuddle with. The plush feels gentle to touch, which makes it perfect for naps or quiet time.

The squeaky feature kept our dogs interested longer than usual. They would shake it and keep bringing it back, which shows it holds their attention well.

However, if your dog is a serious chewer, this might not last long without damage. Still, it’s a nice option for pets who like gentle play or carrying around a soft friend.

goDog Checkers Elephant Plush Toy

The goDog Checkers Elephant is a plush toy that balances softness with added durability for dogs who love to chew but still want a cuddly companion.

Pros

• Chew Guard Technology adds extra strength to the plush material
• Built-in squeakers keep dogs engaged and excited to play
• Soft texture makes it good for cuddling after active play

Cons

• Seams can wear down quickly with very strong chewers
• Not indestructible, so it may need occasional repair
• Some dogs may destroy the toy faster than expected

We found that this toy stands up better than many other plush options thanks to the reinforced lining. It held up well during our play sessions, even with tough chewers around, though we did have to sew a small hole after some aggressive tugging.

The multiple squeakers hidden inside kept our dogs interested longer and encouraged some active play. After that, the elephant’s soft fabric made a comforting snuggle buddy on rest days.

While no toy lasts forever, this one gave us good value by lasting longer than standard plush toys. It’s ideal for households that want a mix of durability and softness in a dog toy.

Outward Hound Fattiez Pig Plush

A solid choice for small to medium dogs, this plush squeaky pig is cute, soft, and holds up better than many similar toys.

Pros

• Soft and gentle on teeth
• Unique squeaky and grunt sounds keep dogs interested
• Minimal seams help with durability

Cons

• Not indestructible; needs supervision
• May not last long with very aggressive chewers
• Small size might not suit large dogs comfortably

We found this little pig to be a great cuddle companion and an entertaining squeaky toy. The sounds it makes aren’t all the same, so it seems to keep dogs curious longer. Our pups like carrying it around and tossing it during playtime.

The toy’s rounded shape is easy on their gums, and the plush material feels nice to bite. Minimal seams add some strength, but we still watch our dogs closely since no plush toy lasts forever with tough chewers.

If you have a small or medium-sized dog that enjoys snuggling or gentle play, this pig is a good pick. For heavier chewers, you might need to replace it sooner, but overall it offers fun and comfort at a fair price.

Multipet Swingin’ Slevin Duck

This big yellow duck is a fun choice for medium to large dogs who love squeaky plush toys with lots of moving parts.

Pros

• Multiple squeakers keep dogs engaged
• Large size works well for bigger dogs
• Soft plush material is good for cuddling

Cons

• Not very durable with strong chewers
• Seams can tear during rough play
• Needs supervision during use

We found the multiple squeakers hidden in the arms, legs, and head really catch dogs’ attention. It’s great for games like fetch or tug of war, especially with larger pups who enjoy carrying something this size.

The soft plush feels nice to the touch and invites cuddling, making it a solid comfort toy as well. Still, the toy doesn’t hold up well against very strong chewers. We’ve seen the seams rip after heavy play, so it’s not the toughest option out there.

Because of that, we recommend watching your dog while they play with this toy to keep it safe and lasting longer. Overall, it’s a fun, interactive plush toy fit for dogs that aren’t terribly aggressive with their chewing.

Hollypet Armadillo Plush Toy

This plush toy is a great pick for small to medium dogs who enjoy soft, noise-making toys that aren’t too loud or harsh.

Pros

• Unique, low-pitch squeak that’s fun but not annoying
• Soft material with a textured surface that soothes gums
• Cute and eye-catching design that suits many dog personalities

Cons

• Not built for aggressive chewers or large dogs
• Stuffing can come out fairly quickly with strong chewers
• Limited to indoor or gentle outdoor play

We found the Hollypet Armadillo to be very charming and gentle. Our dogs carried it around easily and seemed drawn to the quiet grunt sound it makes. Unlike other squeaky toys that can be harsh on the ears, this one had a more pleasant noise.

The material feels soft but slightly tough for a plush toy. It held up well during regular play, but if your dog is a heavy chewer, it might not last very long. For us, this made it perfect for quieter chewing sessions and fetch games.

This toy also helps keep dogs engaged without creating too much mess. It’s clear Hollypet aimed this more at puppies and smaller breeds, which fits well for our household where rough play isn’t the main focus. If your dog is gentle with toys, this is a solid and cute option.

Fuufome Plush Squeaky Dog Toy

This toy is a solid choice for dogs who enjoy plush toys with a squeaker and moderate chewing.

Pros

• Soft fabric that doesn’t hurt gums
• Squeaker keeps dogs interested longer
• Good size for dogs of many breeds

Cons

• Not built for very aggressive chewers
• Smaller than expected from pictures
• Some parts can be chewed off quickly

We found the Fuufome plush has a nice feel and size that fits well with small to large dogs. Its shape and multiple legs make it fun for tugging and tossing during playtime.

The squeaker is loud enough to get dogs excited without being annoying. Our dogs seemed drawn to the realistic eyes, making the toy more engaging.

It did hold up for a fair amount of play, but tough chewers might damage the eyes or fabric more quickly than expected. Still, it works well for indoor fun and cuddle time.

Gumby Plush Dog Toy

This toy is a soft, fun option that brings nostalgia for pet owners and light playtime joy for dogs.

Pros

• Soft, comfortable material that dogs like to cuddle
• Flexible arms and legs make it easy for dogs to carry
• Includes a squeaker that adds extra play fun

Cons

• Not very durable for dogs that chew aggressively
• Some dogs may lose interest quickly
• Squeaker is small and can be damaged easily

We found the Gumby Plush to be a good choice for dogs who like softer toys. Its size fits well for dogs of all breeds, and the flexible arms and legs make it fun to toss or carry around. The bright green color and classic design also caught our eye.

The squeaker adds a bit of excitement but is delicate, so supervision is needed. If your dog is a strong chewer, this toy might not last long. For gentler play or as a cuddly companion, it works well.

Overall, this toy brings a bit of charm and softness to your dog’s collection. It’s a nice gift for puppies and older dogs who prefer plush over tough chew toys.

Duckworth Plush Duck by Multipet

This plush duck is a solid choice for dogs who like soft toys that are large enough to carry and easy to play with.

Pros

• Squeaks to keep dogs interested
• Big enough for large dogs or small dogs that like big toys
• Soft and cuddly for gentle play

Cons

• Not made for rough chewing
• Colors come randomly, so you may not get your preferred one
• Stuffing can come out after long play

We found the Duckworth duck to be really soft and fun for our dog during fetch and cuddle time. The size is just right if you have a bigger dog or a smaller dog with a big personality. The squeaker inside gets our pup excited, but it’s not too loud or annoying.

Because it’s plush and filled with stuffing, it’s best when your dog isn’t a very aggressive chewer. We saw that after a while some of the stuffing started to come out, so it’s important to watch your dog when playing. If the toy gets damaged, it’s safer to replace it.

Overall, it’s a simple toy that lasts longer than many others for a soft toy. It’s a good pick if you want something for tossing, snuggling, and light play without breaking the bank.

Sedioso Plush Donkey Dog Toy

This toy is a solid choice for dogs that enjoy gentle play and squeaky sounds but may not suit strong chewers.

Pros

• Durable cotton weave resists light biting
• Fun squeaky noise that keeps dogs interested
• Lightweight and easy to carry for fetch games

Cons

• Not built for heavy or aggressive chewers
• Size might be smaller than expected for bigger dogs
• Limited color options

The Sedioso plush donkey toy feels soft yet sturdy enough for daily use. We liked how it kept our dogs entertained with the built-in squeaker, which also encouraged interactive play and training. The cotton material and waterproof layer helped keep the toy cleaner after playtime.

It was perfect for indoor fun and calmed our dogs when they were alone. We noticed less chewing on furniture, which helped save our shoes and couch. Its light weight made it easy to toss during fetch, giving our dogs good exercise without tiring us out.

One thing to watch is that this toy won’t survive tough bites for long. It’s better suited for puppies or dogs that are moderate chewers. If your dog is more aggressive, consider something tougher. Overall, it offers good entertainment without being too fragile.

Buying Guide

When choosing plush dog toys, we focus on safety, durability, and size. Toys should be made from non-toxic materials to keep our dogs safe. We look for reinforced seams to prevent stuffing from coming out during play.

Size matters. A toy that is too small can be a choking hazard, while a toy too large might be hard for our dog to carry. We pick toys that match our dog’s size and chewing strength.

We also consider the toy’s purpose. Some plush toys are made for gentle play, while others are designed to last against stronger chewers. Understanding our dog’s play style helps us pick the right toy.

Softness is important too. Plush toys should feel comfortable for our dogs to carry and cuddle, especially if they like to carry toys around or sleep with them.

We also check if the toy has removable parts like eyes or buttons. These can be dangerous if chewed off and swallowed. We avoid toys with small parts or sharp edges.

Lastly, easy cleaning is a plus. Many plush toys can be machine-washed or wiped clean. This keeps toys fresh and safe for our dogs.